Stila's liquid eye liner or Clinique eye defining liquid liner?

I need one in black. Which is better accoring to-


-- intensity of color


-- price


-- how long it wears ( needs to last ALL day )


-- how smudge-proof it is





any personal experiences would also be appreciated :) Thanks in advanceStila's liquid eye liner or Clinique eye defining liquid liner?
I loveee Stila. Everything I've ever tried by them has impressed me. And while I'm also a fan of Clinique, I've never tried their liquid liner. I have tried Stila's, though, and my experience with it was really good. It never smudged, which I always have problems with since I have a big smile. :D I'd give it a try unless something convinces you otherwise.