Is Liquid eye liner any good? is it bettr then the one on the stik?

I like it better because it stays on longer then pencils. Maybelline's Ultra Liner lasts long, but can flake if you rub your eyes.Is Liquid eye liner any good? is it bettr then the one on the stik?
It depends on the brand. I really like it because it lasts longer, doesn't smear or smudge and makes your eyes stand out more. But for your water line I prefer a Kohl or pencil liner.Is Liquid eye liner any good? is it bettr then the one on the stik?
I like it because it doesn't run or smudge, but it tends to flake off and look a bit messy :/.
I think it is. It lasts a lot longer and it looks more intense.